• Forecast
  • News Tip
  • Categories
Temperature Precipitation
Estimated read time
3m 14s

Threatening Facebook posts prompt Supreme Court review

By CBS/AP 5:50 PM June 16, 2014
WASHINGTON –

The Supreme Court will consider the free speech rights of people who use violent or threatening language on Facebook and other electronic media where the speaker’s intent is not always clear.

The court on Monday agreed to take up the case of an eastern Pennsylvania man sentenced to nearly four years in federal prison for posting violent online rants against his estranged wife, law enforcement officials and former co-workers.

A federal appeals court rejected Anthony Elonis’ claim that his comments were protected by the First Amendment. He says he never meant to carry out the threats. He claims he was depressed and made the online posts in the form of rap lyrics as a way of venting his frustration after his wife left him.

At his trial, the jury was instructed that Elonis could be found guilty if an objective person could consider his posts to be threatening. Attorneys for Elonis argue that the jury should have been told to apply a subjective standard and decide whether Elonis meant the messages to be understood as threats.

Elonis’s lawyers say a subjective standard is appropriate given the impersonal nature of communication over the Internet, which can lead people to misinterpret messages. They argue that comments intended for a smaller audience can be viewed by others unfamiliar with the context and interpret the statements differently than was intended.

The Obama administration says requiring proof of a subjective threat would undermine the purpose of the federal law prohibiting threats.

The high court said it will consider whether conviction of threatening another person under federal law “requires proof of the defendant’s subjective intent to threaten.”

For more than 40 years, the Supreme Court has said that “true threats” to harm another person are not protected speech under the First Amendment. But the court has cautioned that laws prohibiting threats must not infringe on constitutionally protected speech. That includes “political hyperbole” or “unpleasantly sharp attacks” that fall shy of true threats.

The federal statute targeting threats of violence is likely to be used more often in the coming years “as our speech increasingly migrates from in-person and traditional handwritten communication to digital devices and the Internet,” said Clay Calvert, a law professor at the University of Florida.

Calvert, one of several free speech advocates who submitted a legal brief urging the court to use a subjective standard, said people mistakenly seem to feel that they can get away with more incendiary speech on the Internet, in tweets and in texts.

Elonis’ estranged wife testified at his trial the postings made her fear for her life. One post about his wife said, “There’s one way to love you but a thousand ways to kill you. I’m not going to rest until your body is a mess, soaked in blood and dying from all the little cuts.”

FBI agents visited Elonis at home after the amusement park that fired him contacted law enforcement officials about his posts. After the agents left, Elonis wrote: “Little agent lady stood so close, took all the strength I had not to turn the (woman) ghost. Pull my knife, flick my wrist and slit her throat.”

The case is Elonis v. United States, 13-983.

In 2012, a British man was charged after posting an offensive status update on Facebook about an abducted 5-year-old girl. Matthew Woods was charged by British police under section 127 of the U.K. Communications Act 2003, which found that his message was “grossly offensive” or “of an indecent, obscene or menacing character.”

© 2014 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Latest Stories

  • News

    No fire hydrants near Eagle River house fire

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Dec 10, 19:06

    More than two dozen firefighting apparatuses were dispatched to a large house fire in Eagle River Saturday evening. Of those, five were water tenders carrying water to the fire, which is in a location void of fire hydrants, according to Assistant Fire Chief Erich Scheunemann. Scheunemann said the first 911 calls came in at 5:18 […]

  • ‘Let justice take its course’: Southcentral Alaska reacts to new arrests in Grunwald murder

    by Eric Ruble on Dec 10, 17:46

    Downtown Palmer is a bright scene this time of year. Colorful lights line the storefronts as people go to and from Colony Christmas events. However, it is tough to go anywhere in the area without overhearing conversations about the death of 16-year-old David Grunwald. Authorities arrested four more teenagers in connection with Grunwald’s death Friday — […]

  • Sports

    UAA volleyball falls in national final

    by Dave Goldman on Dec 10, 16:10

    Last updated at 6:36 p.m. on Saturday, Dec. 10 The run ended one short. After a magical ride, University of Alaska Anchorage Seawolves volleyball team dropped a straight sets match in the Division II National Championship to top-ranked and top-seeded Concordia University St. Paul — 25-19, 25-12, 25-12 — at the Sanford Center in Sioux […]

  • Sports

    Army beats Navy 21-17 to end 14-year losing streak in series

    by David Ginsburg / AP Sports Writer on Dec 10, 14:48

    The U.S. Army ended a 14-year run of frustration against the U.S. Navy, using an overpowering running game and opportunistic defense to carve out a long overdue 21-17 victory Saturday. With future commander-in-chief Donald Trump looking on, the Black Knights blew a 14-point lead before quarterback Ahmad Bradshaw scored on a 9-yard run with 6:42 […]

  • Police: Suspect in Fred Meyer bank robbery caught in nearby mall

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Dec 10, 14:43

    A man police say likely robbed a midtown bank Saturday afternoon has been taken into custody thanks to the help of an observant witness. The robbery was reported around 12:10 p.m. at the Alaska USA located inside the Northern Lights Boulevard Fred Meyer, police said in a statement. “It was reported to police that a […]

  • Troopers involved in shooting with suspect identified

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Dec 10, 14:33

    On Saturday, Alaska State Troopers identified the officers involved in a Dec. 7 shooting that injured a suspect. The four troopers are Lt. Dane Gilmore, Sgt. Jeremy Grieme, Sgt. Michael Zweifel and David Lorring. All have several years of experience with the Alaska Department of Public Safety, according to an online trooper dispatch, and Gilmore […]

  • News

    Turkish minister: 29 killed, 166 wounded in twin bombings

    by KTVA / AP on Dec 10, 14:01

    Last updated at 6 p.m. on Saturday, Dec. 10 Turkey’s Interior Minister Suleyman Soylu says two blasts after an Istanbul soccer match killed have 29 people and wounded 166 others. The twin Saturday night bombings inflicted high casualties among police, killing 27 officers, as well as 2 civilians. In a address early Sunday, the minister said […]

  • Lifestyle

    Bristol Palin announces she is expecting her third child

    by Associated Press on Dec 10, 10:44

    Bristol Palin is expecting her third child, she tells Entertainment Tonight. Former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin’s daughter announced her pregnancy on ET. She and husband Dakota Meyer said they are excited and “blessed” to welcome a baby in the spring. A Palin family spokesman declined to comment. Bristol Palin launched an abstinence campaign after giving […]