• Forecast
  • News Tip
  • Categories
Temperature Precipitation
Estimated read time
6m 29s

The Alaska LNG Project: More questions than answers for lawmakers

By Rhonda McBride 10:01 AM February 27, 2014

Committee hearings shed light on multibillion-dollar project prospects

JUNEAU – Before the legislative session started, the governor, oil industry executives and a pipeline company came up with a road map for bringing North Slope gas to market.

The problem is, it’s a map to a place that none of them have been before. And it’s a road trip they’ve committed to taking together, something they’ve also never done before.

The main road map is a document called the Heads Of Agreement, called this because it was signed by the “heads” of ExxonMobile, ConocoPhillips, BP Exploration, TransCanada and the State of Alaska.

At Senate Finance Committee hearings this week, lawmakers learned that this roadmap is for a journey into undiscovered country; that those who came up with this map really don’t know what’s ahead.

On Wednesday, Sen. Mike Dunleavy pushed for specifics. Mainly, the Wasilla Republican wanted to find out who’s the boss of this trip.

“Who is going to build a pipeline?” Dunleavy asked the partners sitting at the end of the table.

Bill McMahon from Exxon, David Van Tuyl from BP, Pat Flood from Conoco Phillips, Dan Fauske with the state’s Alaska Gasline Development Corporation and Tony Palmer of TransCanada were all part of the conversation.

They best they could come up with?  All of them would build the pipeline, together.

Dunleavy pressed on.

“Is there an entity that’s going to take the lead?” Dunleavy asked.

Finally, a direct answer.

“Today, the lead party for this group is ExxonMobil,” said BP’s Van Tuyl.

Longtime observers of the state’s quest to bring its gas to market said the answer to that question is significant.

It says Exxon is the one at the table that matters the most.

Another revealing set of questions that were posed:  What do the players like and dislike about the project?

“At this point, I don’t see any downsides in the way we are organized,” said Exxon’s McMahon.

“The entities before you represent something like 98 percent of the known gas on the North Slope,” Van Tuyl said.

The players also talked about the cooperation they’ve enjoyed thus far amongst the parties, who have previously been competitors and often in adversarial roles. They talked about this new relationship’s success, almost as if it was a surprise that it was even possible to work together.

“There’s a lot I like about the arrangement,” Van Tuyl said. “The fact that we have all these entities aligned in front of you is tremendously important.”

Important and historical: To see former competitors sitting together at a committee hearing as a team is a new experience for lawmakers.

As for what the partners said they didn’t like? The answers came quickly.

“I think maybe the one thing I don’t like is just looking forward at a price tag of a project that’s potentially as high as $65 billion,” Van Tuyl said.

“I don’t like how much it costs,” Flood said. ”We would love it, if this could be done for a lot less money.”

“The scale of the project is something all parties wish was smaller,” said TransCanada’s Tony Palmer.

“It’s almost hard to put your head around a $60-65 billion project,” said AGDC’s Fauske.

A realization is starting to gel as more of the roadmap gets revealed. It’s more like a map sketched on butcher block paper, not something you find in an atlas or even a pirate’s chest because the treasure — the money — is not located in one place with a great big X mark.

The wealth to be gained is spread across this 800-mile project; from the gas treatment plant on the North Slope, down a pipeline connecting to a liquefaction plant at Nikiski.

The money will come from the fees charged for treating, shipping and processing the gas. There will also be jobs and new infrastructure subject to property taxes, as well as spin-off industries.

But getting liquified natural gas to market requires three megaprojects in one — like climbing Denali, too daunting for any one party to go it alone. In most other LNG projects, the gas is very close to the port where it’s shipped, not across a vast distance of geographically challenged terrain.

Alaska’s share in the project could be as high as $11-17 billion.

For that kind of money, lawmakers understandably want some guarantees as they weigh the merits of Senate Bill 138, the governor’s enabling legislation for the exploratory stage of what’s being called the Alaska LNG Project.

“In this legislation, Alaskans need to know that we are going to benefit from this gas line directly,” said Senator Lyman Hoffman, who represents a district in Southwest Alaska, which has some of the highest energy costs in the world.

For lawmakers, there was acknowledgement at the table that getting gas to Alaskans is part of the plan, and important.

“A successful project will have to get gas to Alaskans,” Van Tuyl said.

The “Heads of Agreement” specifies that the project will include five off-take points from the main pipeline.

But beyond that, there are no specifics about where or how the gas would get to Alaskans.

“Basically those off-take points are a T in the line with a valve, and then what happens downstream of that valve would have to be customized to the customer who would be taking the gas,” said Exxon’s McMahon, who explained that different customers — depending on their needs — will have to have the gas delivered at different pressures.

AGDC’s Dan Fauske explained that it’ll be up to other entrepreneurs to figure how to deliver this gas to Alaskans and make it commercially viable.

Although the state has some of the largest reservoirs of natural gas in the world, getting that gas to Alaskans has never been economical. There aren’t enough Alaskans, and they’re scattered over too great a distance.

But with a line shipping large volumes of gas for export, the concept of getting gas to Alaskans might pencil out.

Tuesday’s discussion in the Senate Finance Committee sharply outlined the competing interests.

The producers are focused on getting gas to markets outside Alaska. That’s where the profit is for them. The state treasury also needs that gas to be sold in large volumes.

And Alaskans, who need just a tiny amount of that gas, will be expensive to serve.

“We want a large amount of gas being sold, so it drives down the price,” Dunleavy said. “But we also have just as an important issue for in-state residents: How do we lower their energy costs?”

These are questions that can’t be answered now, and perhaps for some time.

Finance Committee members were told that this is a gated, staged project. At each phase, the parties will decide whether it’s worth it to go to the next stage. Any one party could also drop out of the project until there’s a decision to build the LNG project, which would come sometime between 2018 and 2019.

The cost for the state for this early engineering and design phase could run as high as half a billion dollars. Lawmakers don’t like the idea that if the project eventually falls through, the state’s money would be gone.

And there’s that risk.

Outside investors would still be needed to bankroll the project. If banks and companies with cash to invest find the Alaska LNG Project too risky, getting North Slope gas to market could remain an impossible dream.

But Fauske summed up the state’s position for moving forward.

“The cost of doing nothing exceeds the cost of the project,” Fauske said.

Latest Stories

  • DayBreak

    GoFundMe page set up for Anchorage coach battling lung cancer

    by Daybreak Staff on Mar 26, 11:18

    He’s encouraged kids to never give up the fight and neither is he, or his friends and family. Local football coach and mentor, Will “Yogi” Foma’i, was diagnosed with lung cancer in November and has been undergoing treatment ever since. “He’s actually doing fairly well,” said Leilua Fadley, Foma’i's sister. “Chemo and treatment is taking […]

  • Politics

    Gov expected to introduce property tax bill for gas project

    by Associated Press on Mar 26, 10:32

    Gov. Bill Walker is expected to introduce legislation setting out a framework for calculating property tax payments for the state and municipalities from a major liquefied natural gas project. Revenue Commissioner Randall Hoffbeck says the formula will lay out a structure so the parties know the variables that will be involved in calculating the payments. […]

  • DayBreak

    Alaskans Pick.Click.Give. their PFD to favorite nonprofits

    by Daybreak Staff on Mar 26, 10:15

    There are more than 45 new organizations Alaskans can donate to this year through Pick.Click.Give. when they sign up for their Permanent Fund Dividend. “There are 540 different organizations [total],” said Kathy Day, Pick.Click.Give. spokesperson. “The list grows every year. Organizations actually apply each year to be a part of Pick.Click.Give. We do vet the […]

  • Lifestyle

    Family of four begins 500-mile trek from Nome to Kotzebue

    by Kristin Leffler / KNOM on Mar 26, 10:14

    As Iditarod mushers were finishing their 1,000-mile journey, a family of four was just beginning their own trek from under the ceremonial burled arch. Bretwood “Hig” Higman, Erin McKittrick, and their two young kids Katmai and Lituya started their 500-mile trek from Nome to Kotzebue on Friday. Over the next few months, they plan to walk, […]

  • Weather

    Daybreak weather, March 26

    by Brett Shepard on Mar 26, 9:02

    Southcentral Rain for the Prince William Sound and eastern Kenai Peninsula. Mostly cloudy skies for the rest of the region. Southeast Cloudy skies with rain at times throughout the day. Interior  Mostly to partly cloudy skies with record warmth possible for parts of the region. North Slope Mostly cloudy skies for most of the region. […]

  • News

    Germanwings tragedy was no accident

    by CBS/AP on Mar 26, 8:07

    Last Updated Mar 26, 2015 10:54 AM EDT SEYNE-LES-ALPES, France - Only the co-pilot of Germanwings Flight 9525 was in the cockpit when the Airbus A320 slammed into a steep mountainside in the French Alps, a French prosecutor confirmed Thursday, saying he had “intentionally” crashed the aircraft. French prosecutor Brice Robin said in Marseille on Thursday that the […]

  • News

    Volcano in western Aleutians shows signs of unrest

    by Associated Press on Mar 26, 7:28

    The Alaska Volcano Observatory is keeping an eye on a western Aleutians Island volcano that last erupted in 1987. The observatory has upgraded the alert level to “advisory” for Semisopochnoi Volcano, indicating it’s exhibiting signs of elevated unrest above known background levels. The volcano is 2,625 feet high. It’s on an uninhabited island 40 miles […]

  • News

    Judge orders release of AO37 emails

    by Bonney Bowman on Mar 26, 6:47

    Voters will learn what role, if any, Anchorage mayoral candidate Dan Coffey played in crafting a controversial labor ordinance. A judge has ordered the municipality to release thousands of emails written during the creation of AO37, which voters repealed in November. Nine local unions filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request to see the […]