• Forecast
  • News Tip
  • Categories
Temperature Precipitation
Estimated read time
2m 11s

Supreme Court rules in ‘Katie John case’

By Heather Hintze 7:41 PM March 31, 2014

Denies the state's request to review a previous decision regarding the federal government's control over rural waterways


“I just want to say thank you,” said Kathryn Martin as she choked back tears. “Thank you to everyone. I thank the Lord for this day.”

Martin’s grandmother, Katie John, fought for decades for subsistence rights for Alaska Natives.

Monday morning the U.S. Supreme Court denied the State of Alaska’s request to review the initial ruling.

“This is also a victory for Alaska Natives and other rural Alaskans who depend on subsistence to feed their families,” said Alaska Federation of Natives (AFN) Co-Chair Tara Sweeney. “And it’s also a victory for Alaskans who seek a prosperous, fair and equitable society. This really is a good day for the Alaska Native community.”

John initially took up the cause in the 1980s when the state closed fishing water she and her ancestors had used for generations.

By giving the federal government control over the land and the water, it would also allow Alaska Natives to continue to fish those waters.

Gov. Sean Parnell asked the court to overturn the federal rules regarding water rights that were promulgated in 1999. The case —  State of Alaska v. Sally Jewell, Secretary of the United States Department of Interior et al — which came to be known as the “Katie John case,” sought to keep the federal control.

“The state’s rural residents harvest about 22,000 tons of wild food each year, an average of 375 pounds per person, said AFN President Julie Kitka. “Fish makes up nearly 60 percent of the harvest by subsistence users each year. Nowhere else in the United States is there such a heavy reliance on fish and game to feed families.”

John’s family said they’re proud of the legacy she left behind and knows she’d be happy with the decision as well.

The Alaska Attorney General’s Office responded to the decision in a written statement:

The State is disappointed today by the news that the Supreme Court has denied hearing the case between the State of Alaska and the Department of Interior and will not move forward to clarify the lines of management authority between the state and federal subsistence programs in Alaska. Until this ambiguity can be removed and a clear definition of jurisdiction can be drawn, the dual management program will continue to lead to litigation and further uncertainty to the detriment of the Alaskan people as a whole.

John’s family said they’re proud of her legacy and know she’d be happy with the decision as well.

“She would be relieved. I can hear her saying, ‘Good, finally done.’ ‘No more,’” laughed Martin.

Latest Stories

  • Victoria’s Secret opens in Alaska, 70 jobs added with more to come

    by Sierra Starks on Oct 28, 11:12

    Starting today, shoppers will have more options when looking to buy lingerie in Anchorage. Victoria’s Secret opened its doors in Alaska at 8 a.m. Friday. There were easily 200 people lined up before staff gathered for the ribbon cutting, said Kari Skinner, director of marketing for the Anchorage 5th Avenue Mall. Staff were on-hand fitting customers for […]

  • November tradition returns with the GCI Great Alaska Shootout

    by Daybreak Staff on Oct 28, 10:59

    An annual Thanksgiving tradition continues this year with the 2016 GCI Great Alaska Shootout. Friday, University of Alaska Anchorage (UAA) athletic director Keith Hackett joined Paul Landes, senior vice president of consumer services at GCI, to discuss this year’s shootout. The women’s teams attending this year are: UAA, Missouri State, Portland and Southern California. The men’s […]

  • News

    Village of Gulkana looks to Gov. Walker to ‘right a wrong,’ get back burial grounds

    by Sierra Starks on Oct 28, 10:30

    Nestled in the woods just north of Glennallen lie the descendants of the Ewan family. If Roy S. Ewan had to guess how many were buried beneath the surface, his guess would be “about 100.” The deceased are family members of the Gulkana tribe, an Athabascan village that used to call the cemetery and its surrounding acres […]

  • News

    FPD’s Sgt. Brandt back in hospital following eye surgery complications

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Oct 28, 9:38

    The Fairbanks Police Department announced Friday that Sgt. Allen Brandt, who was shot multiple times in an altercation with a suspect Oct. 16, has been hospitalized with complications following the scheduled eye surgery Thursday in Anchorage. According to the department, Brandt is currently sedated and receiving treatment. “Out of respect to the Brandt family we are not […]

  • DayBreak

    Daybreak Adopt-a-Pet for Oct. 28, 2016

    by Daybreak Staff on Oct 28, 9:00

    From Anchorage Animal Care and Control: Lulu: She is still waiting for her new home. In the meantime, she’s been keeping herself busy with treat puzzles and cuddling with volunteers. Edgar: Give him a chance and Edgar will reach out to steal your heart. This handsome boy is reserved and quietly affectionate – purring softly while you rub […]

  • News

    Sutton man killed in Glenn Highway crash

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Oct 28, 8:33

    A man is dead and another is injured following a late-night collision on the Glenn Highway Thursday. According to an Alaska State Troopers online dispatch, troopers responded to a crash at 11:05 p.m. Thursday at mile marker 52 of the Glenn Highway. AST stated their investigation led them to believe two pickup trucks, one heading […]

  • News

    Kenai borough overturns mayor’s veto of invocation rules

    by Associated Press on Oct 28, 7:20

    The Kenai Peninsula Borough Assembly has voted to override the mayor’s veto of a new policy on invocations at assembly meetings. The Peninsula Clarion reports the assembly revised its policy earlier this month to only allow members of religious groups with an established borough presence to give the invocation at the start of each meeting. Borough […]

  • Politics

    Libertarian vice presidential candidate in Alaska to campaign for Gary Johnson

    by Daniella Rivera on Oct 27, 22:11

    With less than two weeks to election day, it’s crunch time for campaigns. Thursday, former Massachusetts Gov. Bill Weld, Libertarian presidential candidate Gary Johnson’s running mate, became the first candidate on a 2016 presidential ticket to make a campaign stop in Alaska. During a town hall event he told voters they’re aiming for the White House and […]