• Forecast
  • News Tip
  • Categories
Temperature Precipitation
Estimated read time
1m 36s

Setnet ban: Judge lets ballot initiative process move forward

By Rhonda McBride 11:18 PM July 23, 2014
ANCHORAGE –

It looks like the Cook Inlet fish wars will soon ramp up to a new level. Voters may have a chance to decide whether to ban setnets in urban areas.

The Alaska Fisheries Conservation Alliance (AFCA), which represents sport fishermen, has scored a major court victory.

Alaska Superior Court Judge Catherine Easter ruled favorably on the alliance’s petition to ban setnetting on Wednesday.

Although the petition doesn’t specifically name Cook Inlet setnetters, the language of the petition appears to target them.

The setnetters fish for sockeyes, but catch kings incidentally. AFCA wants to stop them from fishing completely. While this might help protect the endangered king salmon, it would also make more Cook Inlet salmon available for sport fishermen and dipnetters.

The judge said Lt. Governor Mead Treadwell was wrong to block the petition.

Treadwell based his decision on an opinion from the Alaska Department of Law, which said the petition violates provisions in the Alaska constitution — which treats fish and game resources as a state asset.

Treadwell said the proposed initiative, if passed, would have the effect of allocating fish between user groups. The Department’s opinion also said the passage of the initiative could set a bad precedent — that the state might face future petition drives seeking to outlaw other gear types.

Opponents of the petition have decried it as “ballot box biology,” and said fishery allocation decisions should be made by the Alaska Board of Fisheries.

“Alaskans have a long history of using ballot initiatives to protect fish and game,” said the AFCA’s attorney Matt Singer in a prepared statement.

The next step for the alliance is to collect 35,000 signatures — the required number to put the measure on the ballot.

The AFCA aims to put the initiative before voters in 2016.

Click here to see the judge’s order.

Latest Stories

  • On-Air

    Teacher of the Week: John Bruce

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Nov 24, 10:37

    You wouldn’t consider these seventh-grade algebra students football fanatics. But you can bet they know who the defending Super Bowl champions are. In a way, Seattle Seahawks fan John Bruce is like coach in the classroom, teaching his students ways to use math in the real world. “Kids always ask you, ‘why are we doing […]

  • News

    Hawaii and Alaska pay more for Thanksgiving feasts

    by Associated Press on Nov 24, 8:57

    Residents of Hawaii pay the highest prices in the nation for their tasty birds and fixings on Thanksgiving, and Alaska feasts are almost as expensive. That’s according to an analysis by the personal finance website NerdWallet. Most food has to be flown or shipped into both states. The Honolulu Star-Advertiser reports (http://goo.gl/6HhPO2) that Hilo and […]

  • Sports

    UAA rebounds with a 4-0 win against Northern Michigan

    by KTVA Sports on Nov 24, 8:12

    It should be a happy Thanksgiving for the UAA hockey team after a victory over the Northern Michigan Wildcats over the weekend.

  • Sports

    UAA teams gain momentum ahead of Great Alaska Shootout

    by KTVA Sports on Nov 24, 8:04

    As the Great Alaska Shootout approaches, the UAA men’s and women’s basketball teams are headed in the right direction. The tournament, which kicks off Tuesday, will be held at the Alaska Airlines Center.

  • Weather

    Daybreak weather, Nov. 24

    by Brett Shepard on Nov 24, 7:50

    Mostly cloudy skies today with a few showers over the Kenai Peninsula and Prince William Sound. In the Southeast skies will be cloudy with rain at times. In the Interior skies will be cloudy. On the North Slope there will be mostly to partly cloudy skies with flurries and fog. Out West skies will be […]

  • News

    Geothermal energy at Pilgrim Hot Springs could help Nome’s costly power problem

    by Alexis Fernandez on Nov 24, 7:33

    Alaska’s oil boom days may be more numbered than we realize. Because of this, a popular hot springs near Nome is hoping to tap into an underground heat source to help solve its rising electricity costs. The site is located on the outskirts of Nome, about 60 miles away in a valley surrounded by mountains. “It’s […]

  • Lifestyle

    Photo Gallery: Dall sheep along Seward Highway

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Nov 24, 7:11

  • News

    Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel resigning

    by CBS News on Nov 24, 7:06

    Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel is resigning, CBS News National Security Correspondent David Martin has learned, and will leave his position after less than two years at the helm of the Defense Department. A senior defense official told Martin the resignation is a “mutual decision” between Hagel and President Obama that has been under discussion for […]