• Forecast
  • News Tip
  • Categories
Temperature Precipitation
Estimated read time
2m 2s

Pipeline value discrepancy settled in Supreme Court

By Emily Carlson 12:56 AM February 20, 2014

Ruling means the boroughs stand to collect hundreds of millions of dollars more in property taxes.

ANCHORAGE – It was a huge victory for some Alaska communities after the Alaska Supreme Court ruled on how the state should determine the value of the trans-Alaska pipeline.

For years Fairbanks, Valdez and North Slope boroughs have claimed the state was devaluing the pipeline, costing them hundreds of millions of dollars in property taxes.

In 2006, the boroughs filed a complaint with the State Assessment Review Board.

The problem was a discrepancy of value. The oil companies claim the pipeline is only worth $850 million, the state said it was worth $3.6 billion, while the boroughs said it’s worth more than $11 billion. So who’s right? On Wednesday, the Alaska Supreme Court said the boroughs are calculating correctly.

The ruling clears up the long-debated question as to how the state should determine how much the pipeline is worth. A former member of the State Assessment Review Board told KTVA the state had been using an approach that assumed the pipeline would last 30 years.

The boroughs argued for a different approach, assuming that the pipeline will last 60 to 90 years. That’s the approach the Supreme Court ruled was correct. It means the boroughs stand to collect hundreds of millions of dollars more in property taxes.

“I think this decision is a victory for Alaskans and for Alaska communities,” said former State Assessment Review Board Member Marty McGee.  ”It’s an appropriate decision and it’s fair. That’s what we in assessment try to base it on. If you have to pay a tax on your home based on the value of your home, then the owners of the pipeline should pay a tax based in fair value of the pipeline.”

McGee was dismissed from the board last month. He claims it was a move by the Gov. Sean Parnell to stack the board in favor of the oil industry.

However, a Parnell spokesperson denied that claim, saying the governor wanted a fresh perspective on the board.

As for Wednesday’s Supreme Court ruling, spokeswoman Sharon Leighow said the governor hasn’t had a chance to read the 50-page ruling.

“Although we are still reviewing the decision, the state’s methodology, upheld by the court, leaves more money in the people’s treasury,” she released in a statement.

The ruling stems from a dispute that stretches all the way back to 2006. That means property owners now owe municipalities seven years of back taxes. What still isn’t clear is if they will also owe interest on those back taxes.

Latest Stories

  • News

    Pedestrian killed in 5th Avenue collision

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Feb 13, 19:01

    The Anchorage Police Department is at the scene of a fatal collision near the intersection of Fifth Avenue and Concrete Street. A male pedestrian was struck and killed during the incident, which occurred just before 6:30 p.m., according to police. He was pronounced dead at the scene despite lifesaving measures performed by witnesses. Police said […]

  • News

    Obama: I plan to nominate a successor to Justice Scalia

    by CBS News on Feb 13, 17:51

    President Obama commemorated deceased Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia Saturday evening but also promised to nominate a successor in due time, in spite of Republicans who are say that responsibility belongs to the next president. “Obviously today is a time to remember Justice Scalia’s legacy. I plan to fulfill my Constitutional responsibilities to nominate a […]

  • News

    Quintillion plans to deliver fiber optic cable and high-speed Internet by early 2017

    by Laura Kraegel/KNOM on Feb 13, 17:44

    After delays last year, Quintillion Networks has an update on the fiber optic cable project that will bring high-speed internet to western Alaska. The company will start laying cable in June and finish construction in early September. That’s according to Tim Woolston, a spokesperson for the Anchorage-based company. He said local customers should have faster […]

  • News

    U.S. Supreme Court Justice Scalia dead at 79

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Feb 13, 13:50

      Justice Scalia dead at 79. — Scotus (@Scotus) February 13, 2016   ANCHORAGE — U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia was found dead Saturday morning. He was 79. CBS News reports Scalia was found dead in his room at the Cibolo Creek Ranch, a West Texas resort. The cause of his death was not […]

  • News

    Library, gym at Anchorage school closed due to earthquake damage

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Feb 13, 13:21

    A recent 7.1 magnitude earthquake damaged the library and gym of Romig Middle School, according to Anchorage School District officials. The damage was extensive enough to warrant closing both facilities to the public until repairs can be made. Following the Jan. 24 earthquake, assessments were done at all Anchorage schools, including Romig Middle School. The […]

  • Crime

    Ekwok man pleads down in attempted murder case

    by Dave Bendinger / KDLG on Feb 13, 10:21

    Michael J. Kawaglia, 45, reached a deal with state prosecutors and pleaded guilty to second degree assault Wednesday. Kawaglia had originally been charged with a number of crimes, including attempted first degree murder, for a vicious assault against his mother in September 2014. The unprovoked attack happened early morning at the woman’s Ekwok home. According […]

  • Sports

    In Willow, return of Iditarod is more about pride than money

    by Eric Ruble on Feb 13, 9:40

    In less than one month, the area around Willow Lake will be jammed with more than 15,000 people for the Iditarod restart. It was announced Friday that the restart will take place at its traditional home in Willow, as opposed to Fairbanks, where the restart was relocated last year due to a lack of snow. […]

  • News

    Mat-Su man rebuilding after being conned by woman he met online

    by Bonney Bowman on Feb 12, 22:36

    A Mat-Su Valley man is picking up the pieces after being conned by a woman he met on an online dating website. When Kenneth Wilson met Rebecca Elise on the dating site plentyoffish.com, it wasn’t necessarily love at first message. “I was a little bit stand-offish at first because obviously she wasn’t a resident of […]