Mental Health Care in U.S. Questioned Amid Another Tragedy (With CBS News Video)

Tools

By Ryan Jaslow / CBS News

He added that the mental health care infrastructure just isn't there compared to care for other diseases. For example, a patient with cancer would be placed on a scientifically-backed comprehensive treatment plan with well-trained doctors for chemotherapy, radiation, etc., whereas people seeking mental health treatment need to do more work on their end not only find treatment but overcome these disincentives to get care.

While some individuals and their families may know there's a mental health problem, Lieberman said they may not take the recommended treatment because the U.S. does not require people to receive mental health treatment unless there's a risk of harm.

Even if it gets to that point, there are barriers.

Lieberman said there is a high threshold for evidence and risk for danger, in that someone has to have specific plans to cause harm, rather than just being someone with anger or self-control issues who may pose a threat. Even then, the doctor would need to call the appropriate law enforcement, fill out paperwork and go through a "cumbersome" process to get action, Lieberman said.

"In one way you got to protect the confidentiality and rights of patients, the other hand, we have the duty to protect society," he said. "Right now, the balance is tipped in favor of the individual against the interests of society."

Mental health care likely is not the only factor, he said, adding the American culture has more sensationalized violence on television, movies and video games than anyone growing up in the nineteenth century could have ever imagined.

However, when much of the focus has turned to gun control and what laws can be passed to prevent such an occurrence, those like Long want to shift the focus to other ways to provide more help for parents of a troubled child.

"Our society, with its stigma on mental illness and its broken healthcare system, does not provide us with other options," she wrote. "Then another tortured soul shoots up a fast food restaurant. A mall. A kindergarten classroom. And we wring our hands and say, 'Something must be done.' I agree that something must be done. It's time for a meaningful, nation-wide conversation about mental health."

Previous 12

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Dec 19 at 8:47 AM

imbalances with the body start with the simplest of measures...vitamins and minerals...the old time doctor is right...making a mountain out of a molehill is a racket with mental health I will admit...but start with lots of water...it washes away those pesky places in your body where stuff collects and starts to cause problems...vitamins and minerals balance your body and mind...like getting your tires balanced...like that analogy... anyways...get the to medical doctor before a mental one...most of them want you up and running so to speak not all doped up and crashed...there is no long range profits in that in terms of business and investors say they want everyone to be working...some I know are pulling away from mental health investments...gee was it something I said I asked...smirk...more money in people working then at home all vegitated from drugs... more money to the economy and your wallet I said...ok I might have been a little BLUNT..;)

109576086
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Tuesday, Dec 18 at 4:29 PM

Mental Health, like most supposed healthcare is nothing more than a snake oil selling racket. Getting people addicted to medication has been going on since before the turn of last century, not to be outdone by the millions that had been poisoned in Europe throughout the centuries. These people aren't doctors they're poisoners...

109528126
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Tuesday, Dec 18 at 12:45 PM

uh what does the Nazi's have to do with some poor kid who was able to get to too many guns and do too much damage...we all understand the system is a racket and society will correct it accordingly...I like the old time doctors idea of engaging in a talk with someone instead of glaring at them and looking away...the old school were pretty nosy..lol..still are...but we love you...but the younger kids are isolated and live in a bubble of reality when the real world is different...that is how it gains momentum...we can do something without doing anything at all it sounds to me like with the old time doctors advice...lol..good idea really...hmmm...

109510836
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

WHAT EVER HAPPENED TO FAMILY VALUES? said on Tuesday, Dec 18 at 11:23 AM

IF they are so keen on prevention why did famous killers like Hitler, under the care of Psychiatry during the war and before it, not get treated? Answer because he gave them lost of money and power to run the death camps. In fact when Jews were going to be simply deported it was a Psychiatrist who offered another easier solution - death camps. Why? Because Jews were suffering from a mental illness - so these Doctors said. As part of Jewish-American family I am sick of the murdering false doctors getting away with the scam. Consider this, Dr. Karl Brandt (January 8, 1904 – June 2, 1948) was a German Nazi Psychiatrist. Among other positions, Brandt headed the administration of the Nazi euthanasia program (which was a Psychiatric run program) The euthanasia pgm was known as T-4 and began in autumn 1939 under Karl Brandt. Look him up. The fact he was a Psych doctor who ran this program was swept under the carpet by his fellow Doctors worried about losing lost of money and power.

109503916
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

old time doctor said on Tuesday, Dec 18 at 11:00 AM

check the mineral level and vitamin levels...local public health has tests...most of the time it can be cured without drugs and self-esteem and self-enrichment classes then a doctor and some will prescribe just that...but most are in it for the $$ and the pharmaceuticals support private practices of psychiatry that make money not progress...the revolving door of mental health...society can assist many to listen and refer to the local public health centers...free.. then they might seek help...encourage them...if you refer mental health to a car it's easier... sounds like your "fill in the blank" is going bad better get to the mechanic and get it checked out then stigmas are gone...and it's joked about and as if everyone has a part that needs fixing once in a while...moods soften and they seek help... well some do with encouragement as well...

109501456
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

WHAT EVER HAPPENED TO FAMILY VALUES? said on Tuesday, Dec 18 at 10:29 AM

Psychiatry is a huge fraud. Look at what their own leaders have said, “There are no objective tests in psychiatry, no X-ray, laboratory, or exam finding that says definitively that someone does or does not have a mental disorder.” —Allen Frances, Former DSM-IV Task Force Chairman “We do not know the causes [of any mental illness]. We don’t have the methods of ‘curing’ these illnesses yet.” —Dr. Rex Cowdry, psychiatrist and director of National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), 1995 “The time when psychiatrists considered that they could cure the mentally ill is gone. In the future the mentally ill have to learn to live with their illness.” —Norman Satorius, president of the World Psychiatric Association in 1994

109497766
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Cecilia Preziose said on Tuesday, Dec 18 at 10:27 AM

Mental Health Insurance, follow care, and diagnosis is the answer for a healthier population. We don't live in a perfect world there will always be health issues. We just don't see mental illness, gun control will not prevent or even com close to preventing mass shootings

109497562
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

KTVA CBS 11 | Anchorage, Alaska News and Weather and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.