• Forecast
  • News Tip
  • Categories
Temperature Precipitation
Estimated read time
2m 43s

If U.S. taxes are so progressive, why the inequality gap?

By Aimee Picchi/CBS News 1:02 PM May 13, 2014

In the debate over America’s increasing income inequality, some of the rhetoric has focused on the country’s tax system, with calls for heftier burdens placed on the country’s wealthiest. Heck, even millionaires say they and their cohorts should face higher taxes.

That’s prompted some critics to point to a 2008 report from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, which stated that the U.S. has the most progressive tax system among developed countries. Therefore, some conservative groups such as the American Enterprise Institute have argued, America is already addressing inequality and should be held up as a “redistributive paradise.”

Not so fast, argues the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities in a report issued Monday. Some of the analyses are “cherry picking” and distorting the OECD’s findings, the report’s authors argue, noting that the conclusions aren’t as rosy as some would like to think. Instead, the American system of taxes and cash transfers — such as Social Security payments — are doing less to reduce inequality than almost any other OECD country, despite the country’s progressive tax.

So how does that work? After all, if a country’s tax system taxes wealthy people at higher levels than the poor, shouldn’t that help to narrow income inequality?

There are two big issues with the U.S. system that are actually putting it behind other developed countries, the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities reports.

“The answer is that tax progressivity by itself gives an incomplete picture of how much taxes and cash transfers reduce inequality,” authors Chye-Ching Huang and Nathaniel Frentz wrote.

First of all, the overall amount raised by taxes directly impacts how a country can address inequality: The less money raised through taxes, the fewer resources a country has to redirect those funds to lower-income families, for example. And taxes in the U.S., despite its progressive policies, represent a smaller share of household income (about 26 percent) than in the average OECD country (at about 29 percent, excluding the U.S.)

Secondly, the U.S. spends less on cash transfers — at about 9 percent of household cash disposable income — than almost any other country in the OECD, and about half as much as the OECD country average of 22 percent.

“As a result, while U.S. income and employee payroll taxes were the most progressive in the OECD, they were only the fourth most effective in reducing income inequality,” the report notes.

Regardless of interpretation, the fact remains that inequality is growing in the U.S., as well as other developed countries. The top 1 percent of Americans now take home 20 percent of all pre-tax income in the country, or double their share in 1980, the OECD reported earlier this month.

And despite higher taxes as a percentage of GDP in countries such as Denmark and Germany, inequality is also rising in those countries, albeit at a slower rate than in in the U.S.

© 2014 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.

Latest Stories

  • Crime

    ‘Disconcerting and sad’: Neighborhood reacts to double homicide

    by Eric Ruble on Aug 29, 20:30

    Early Monday morning, the playground at Valley of the Moon Park was filled with families. Nearby, bicyclists rode down the trail. But Yuki Varnell, who comes here regularly with her daughter, says there are fewer people than usual following Sunday’s double homicide. “Knowing something like this could happen and having the kids around, I would […]

  • Crime

    Former JBER soldier pleads guilty to multiple Anchorage sexual assaults

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Aug 29, 19:42

    A former Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson soldier accused of attacking multiple women and sexually assaulting some of them in 2013 pleaded guilty Monday to charges related to the crimes. Two sexual assault victims reported the attacks to police in mid-July 2013. The victims described the suspect very similarly, an affidavit from Anchorage police officer John Vandervalk […]

  • Lifestyle

    Many with depression have something else in common

    by Mary Brophy Marcus / CBS News on Aug 29, 19:35

    U.S. health officials recommended earlier this year that everyone over 18 should be routinely screened for depression, but spotting signs of the problem is just the first step. What happens next? Too often, those who have depression aren’t actually getting the treatment they need, a new study suggests. Researchers from Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, in New York, wanted to find out if people […]

  • News

    Newlywed couple seeks help in search for missing wedding day photos

    by Shannon Ballard on Aug 29, 18:51

    A newly married couple says they are heartbroken after losing hundreds of once-in-a-lifetime photos of their wedding day. Shanda Ring and Greg Zhuk tied the knot at the Alyeska Resort over the weekend. Afterwards they went up to Matanuska Glacier to take pictures and accidentally left their Nikon D3200 camera on a log behind the information stand. “This […]

  • News

    Bartlett High celebrates math culture with perfect scores

    by Lauren Maxwell on Aug 29, 18:38

    You could call it a school where math is cool. The school in question is Bartlett High School, where principal Sean Prince said they have turned some math scores around. Prince said four years ago, the school had a reputation for having poor student math scores, and it was obvious change was needed. They decided […]

  • Lifestyle

    Head gardener brightens Alaska State Fair with flowers

    by Heather Hintze on Aug 29, 18:30

    For more than three decades, Becky Myrvold has been brightening up the Alaska State Fair grounds with flowers. As head gardener, her growing season begins in January, starting 50,000 plants from seed. “My job is year round and as soon as the fair gets done, I’ll start planning for next year,” Myrvold said. Her flowers […]

  • News

    Key witness in Reid case raises concern about ‘bad apple’ defense

    by Adrian Wagner/KYUK on Aug 29, 17:13

    This story originated from KYUK Public Media and was republished with permission. BETHEL — State prosecutors last week used the term “bad apple” to describe former Bethel Police Officer Andrew Reid, who pled guilty to assault and misconduct charges in the beating of an Alaska Native man.  A key witness in the case doesn’t think that’s the […]

  • Lifestyle

    The new economic face of marriage

    by CBS News on Aug 29, 16:46

    The opening line of the Sinatra song “Love and Marriage” might need to be updated to include to, “Love, a college degree, and marriage go together like a horse and carriage.” During the past 25 years, marriage rates have been climbing for women with college and graduate degrees, while women who lack an education beyond […]