• Forecast
  • News Tip
  • Categories
Temperature Precipitation
Estimated read time
2m 1s

High school exit exam leaves some students behind

By Alexis Fernandez 10:05 PM March 4, 2014

School counselors weigh in on high school exit exam debate

ANCHORAGE – To test or not to test? That’s the question being debated in high schools across Alaska, including at East High School.

As state lawmakers debate whether to eliminate the high school exit exam, some school counselors are weighing in.

“There isn’t a significant benefit except for kids that pass it,” said Scott Henry, an ELL counselor at East High School.

Henry says he sees the downside of the High School Graduation Qualifying Exam (HSGQE) firsthand.

“It’s really tragic to see kids that work really, really, really hard for three or four years once they get here, to be one or two points away,” Henry said.

He says the group being left behind, is the English Language Learner (ELL) students.

“If a student comes here when they’re 16 or 17 — and they’re brand new to the country and brand new to the language, the reality of them passing those tests is low,” Henry said.

According to Henry, out of the nearly 500 students who graduated from East last year, 50 failed the test and didn’t get a diploma. Instead they got a Certificate of Achievement.

He says although it’s a small percentage, these students will eventually impact the future workforce.

“They aren’t able to get into college, and even with the military, only some branches are accepting a certificate of attendance,” he continued.

According to Alaska Department of Education, the exit exam went into effect in 2004.

Since then, 2,388 students have received a certificate instead of a diploma. Last year, 364 were given — 132 of those were ELL students.

Here in Anchorage, 108 certificates were given out last year, about three percent of the graduating class.

Henry says the current culture of testing is hurting students, rather than helping.

“Not having it tied to whether they get a diploma, that might be a much more functional approach than having this hard line that says if you can’t pass it, you don’t earn a diploma,” Henry said.

But not everyone agrees. David Nees, a retired Anchorage School District teacher of 25 years, says the exam serves a purpose.

“It lets the public know that when you have a high school degree, that you actually are kind of competent, in reading, writing and mathematics,” Nees said.

And believes it needs to stay.

“It’s the only measurement that we have right now that actually meaures mastery in something,” he said.

Two very different answers to a complicated debate that is far from over.

Latest Stories

  • Crime

    2 charged in Mountain View Smoke King robbery

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Apr 19, 10:54

    Two suspects have been arrested and charged in the robbery of the Smoke King shop, located in Mountain View. An armed robbery was reported to the Anchorage Police Department just after 7 p.m. Saturday. The caller said that “a male armed with a gun demanded money from an employee at the Smoke King and then […]

  • Crime

    Suspected DUI crash in East Anchorage leaves motorcyclist in critical condition

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Apr 19, 10:36

    A motorcyclist is in the hospital in critical condition after he was struck by a driver who police believe was impaired. Just after 8:30 p.m. Saturday, the Anchorage Police Department responded to the collision, near the intersection of Debarr Road and Edward Street. Preliminary investigation revealed that a motorcyclist, who APD is identifying as a […]

  • Weather

    Weekend weather forecast

    by KTVA Weather on Apr 18, 19:43

     

  • Crime

    Double shooting in Talkeetna leaves 1 dead, 1 in critical condition

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Apr 18, 13:30

    One man is dead and another is in critical condition after a double shooting in the Montana Creek area of Talkeetna. At about 1 a.m. Saturday, the Palmer Police Department received a 911 call notifying them that a person had been killed, according to a Alaska State Troopers dispatch. “The 911 call came from a […]

  • Politics

    Day 89: Latest from the Alaska Legislature

    by Associated Press on Apr 18, 12:59

      10:08 p.m. A meeting of House and Senate negotiators was canceled late Saturday, without major issues, like education funding, being resolved. The Legislature’s rules call for a conference report on the budget to sit at least 24 hours after being delivered to the chief clerk of the House or Senate secretary, though it may […]

  • Politics

    AKLeg Day 88: Race to the finish of session begins with drama, uncertainty

    by Rhonda McBride on Apr 18, 12:21

    Friday, the 88th day of the 90-day legislative session, was full of the drama that characterizes the end-of-session chaos. The day started out with the governor calling off a joint session of the House and Senate he had ordered, to get lawmakers to vote on his cabinet and board appointments. The governor demanded the session […]

  • Crime

    Man shot outside his Fairview home after going to investigate noise

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Apr 18, 10:27

    Anchorage police say a man was shot outside of his home in Fairview after he heard a noise and went to investigate. Just after 7:30 a.m. Saturday, the Anchorage Police Department received a call reporting that a man had been shot outside of a residence on the 1000 block of E. 13th Avenue. When police […]

  • News

    Gov. Walker steps in to save Govt. Hill bears; Fish & Game will relocate them

    by Shannon Ballard on Apr 18, 0:03

    Updated Saturday, 2:50 p.m. Gov. Bill Walker has stepped in to save the black bear family roaming Government Hill, recommending that the bears be pardoned from being euthanized. The Alaska Department of Fish and Game says the mother and four cubs have a history in Government Hill dating back to last summer when the department […]