• Forecast
  • News Tip
  • Categories
Temperature Precipitation
Estimated read time
6m 5s

Governor’s appointee withdraws from taxation board

By Rhonda McBride 5:38 AM March 14, 2014

Out-of-state appointee highlights a clash between state law and the Alaska Constitution

JUNEAU – A recent appointee to the State Assessment Review Board has bowed out. Dennis Mandell has decided the volunteer position is just too political.

Most Alaskans have probably never heard of SARB, but it’s important to the state’s bottom line, as well as a number of cities and boroughs with property along the trans-Alaska pipeline corridor.

The governor appoints all five of the board’s members. Their job is to review the property taxes of oil and gas companies, and that can get controversial.

Just ask Marty McGee, an Anchorage property tax assessor who advocated for higher taxes.

The governor removed McGee from the board earlier this year and replaced him with Mandell, who had two strikes against him: He lives in Salinas, California and has ties to the oil industry.

Critics like the Senate minority leader were angered by the choice.

“The governor wants to reach outside the state and bring somebody here to make important decisions, economic decisions,” said Sen. Hollis French. “And he wants to use a California oil man to make those decisions.”

“We should govern from within and govern ourselves,” French said. “And for whatever reason, this governor, Sean Parnell, wants to hire outsiders to make those crucial decisions. And in this case, it benefits the oil industry.”

French also believes the governor violated a state law that says you have to be an Alaska resident who was voted in the last general election to serve on a state board or commission.

But Parnell disagrees. He points to the Alaska Constitution which says the only requirement necessary is United States citizenship.

At a news conference Thursday, he defended that right.

“I want to do everything I can to preserve the constitutional authority of this office, as envisioned by the framers of Alaska’s constitution,” Parnell said. “So I had that in mind.”

Parnell also said Mandell was the most qualified of the candidates who applied for the seat.

“He’s an incredibly professional and qualified individual. Everybody who met him thought that,” the governor said. “But the politics of naming an out-of-state resident certainly played into this.”

French believes the governor has tarnished a tradition of appointing Alaskans to serve on boards and commissions going all the way back to the territorial days — when it was important to the emerging state to be free of outside influence and gain control of its destiny.

“This governor is asserting he has a right to do it again, and I think the people of Alaska would reject that,” French said.

House Speaker Mike Chenault, in anticipation of a difficult confirmation process for Mandell, asked a legal analyst from the Legislative Affairs Agency to weigh in.

In their opinion, legislative attorneys said the state constitution likely favors the power of the governor, though they acknowledged a conflict between the constitution and state statutes.

The specific statute in question is AS 39.05.100(a).

It states:

“A person appointed to a board or commission shall be and have been before the last general election, (1) a registered voter in the state…”

The attorneys wrote:

“The appointment of a nonresident of the state violates AS 39.05.100(a). However, there is considerable question of whether AS 39 05.100(a) is constitutional under the federal and state constitutions. Indeed, a court would probably find that AS 39.05.100(a) violates the Constitution of the State of Alaska.”

French said, given the conflict, the governor should have “harmonized” the two laws.

“The governor is saying they don’t reconcile, but I think they do,” said French. “The constitution says you should hire U.S. citizens. The statute says you hire Alaskans. My solution that benefits Alaskans is to hire U.S. citizens who live in the state of Alaska.”

Parnell said it’s possible he or a future governor may attempt to resolve the conflict in court. But since Mandell withdrew, he won’t pursue it at this time.

The governor acknowledged Mandell was part of a plan to take the board in a new direction, one that would be more balanced.

He said boards in the past tended to ask only one question: How could they raise the tax?

“I need board members who Alaskans can trust will follow the law, not tilt the table one way or another,” Parnell said.

A recent Alaska Supreme Court ruling in a 2006 lawsuit has heightened public scrutiny of oil company property taxes. The court found that the industry low-balled the value of the trans-Alaska pipeline by almost $10 billion.

“This is a question in which the municipality says this house is worth $11.5 billion, and the pipeline owner says it’s worth one-tenth of that,” French said. “They offered us a dime on the dollar for the value of the pipeline. They were wrong.”

The governor said the scenario for the pipeline is much different today than in 2006, when oil prices were high and more oil was flowing through the line. He said the declining throughput is hurting the value of the line and it probably won’t go up in value until there is more oil flowing through it.

The governor believes assessors need to take this into consideration.

The 2006 lawsuit has figured prominently in discussions of the governor’s efforts to launch the Alaska Liquified Natural Gas Project.

Oil and gas companies want to do things differently than they did with the trans-Alaska pipeline. Instead of paying property taxes, which are tied to the value of the property and fluctuate, they want to compensate cities and boroughs with Payment in Lieu of Taxes, or PILT.

French said the five SARB board members could be making decisions that could be worth millions of dollars to both state and local governments, which is why each board seat is so important.

For now, it’s a position that’s in the rearview mirror for Mandell, who believes his motives and intent have been mischaracterized.

Years ago, Mandell lived in Alaska and worked for ARCO. He said he raised his family here and still has many ties to the state.

Mandell, who said he is mostly retired, travels to Alaska two or three times a year.

In the past, he has worked on TAPS for the oil industry. He has also worked on the other side of the fence, such as the time he represented the Municipality of Anchorage in a lawsuit against Enstar, a natural gas utility.

The appointment of board members from outside of Alaska is not entirely unprecedented. Some boards, like that of the state-owned Alaska Aerospace Development Corporation, have out-of-state members. A law had to be passed to make this possible, because of the difficulty of finding people with expertise in the aerospace industry in Alaska.

The governor could do the same thing; get a law passed allowing non-residents to serve on the assessment board.

In the meantime, Parnell said he’s ready to move on from the controversy and is already looking for a new candidate.

“I don’t want us to be distracted from these super important topics that will benefit Alaskans,” said Parnell.

But critics have lingering doubts about Parnell’s attempt to put a non-resident on the board. They believe the governor has abused the process, and could do it again to try to stack the deck in favor of oil and gas companies.

Latest Stories

  • Grunwald case suspect now faces federal child porn charges

    by Shannon Ballard on Jan 18, 17:00

    Devin Peterson’s long list of child pornography-related charges has grown to include two federal charges. If that name sounds familiar, it’s because the 18-year-old is one of the five Valley teens arrested in connection with David Grunwald’s murder. Alaska State Troopers seized Peterson’s phone during that investigation and found a disturbing video that could send […]

  • News

    By the numbers: Donald Trump’s $200 million inauguration

    by Aimee Picchi/CBS News on Jan 18, 16:19

    Last Updated Jan 18, 2017 5:45 PM EST Donald Trump has promised that his inauguration will “very, very special, very beautiful.” By one measure, the event will definitely be as “bigly” as Mr. Trump envisions, given his inaugural committee has raised a record $90 million in private donations to help cover the tab. And oh, […]

  • News

    Alaska volcano erupts again, sends ash cloud to 31,000 feet

    by KTVA / AP on Jan 18, 16:07

    An Alaska volcano active since mid-December has erupted again. Bogoslof Volcano in the Aleutian lslands erupted at 1:20 p.m. Wednesday and sent up an ash cloud that pilots reported was estimated at 31,000 feet. “Bogoslof volcano is in an active eruption sequence that began on December 16, though retrospective analysis suggests unrest may have started […]

  • News

    Troopers: Fairbanks man overdue from snowmachine trip found dead

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Jan 18, 15:36

    Search teams found a Fairbanks man’s body Tuesday after he didn’t return home from a snowmachine trip. Alaska State Troopers spokeswoman Megan Peters said in an online dispatch that 27-year-old Travis Loughridge was reported missing on Monday morning; the same day he was expected to return from his trip. Loughridge left Shungnak on Friday around noon […]

  • Weather

    Coldest temperatures in several years recorded around Alaska

    by Rachael Penton on Jan 18, 14:35

    A statewide cold snap is underway in Alaska. Numerous locations through the central and western Interior recorded temperatures in range of minus 40 to minus 55. The Fairbanks International Airport recorded a temperature of 50 below zero for the first time since Jan. 29, 2012. Ralph M. Calhoun Memorial Airport in Tanana observed a temperature of […]

  • Anchorage police shut down section of Northern Lights to stop car theft

    by KTVA CBS 11 News on Jan 18, 13:45

    Updated at 5:10 p.m. on Wednesday, Jan. 18 Police shut down a section of Northern Lights Boulevard in Anchorage as officers tried to stop a stolen vehicle. Late Wednesday morning, the Anchorage Police Department sent a text message alert stating that traffic was stopped on Northern Lights between Nichols and Bragaw Streets. According to an officer […]

  • DayBreak

    Workforce Wednesday: Millwrights

    by Daybreak Staff on Jan 18, 13:18

    Millwrights are precision industrial mechanics that work on compressors, turbines and other heavy equipment. This field includes high paying jobs servicing equipment that keeps Alaska’s major industries, like fishing and mining, afloat. Interested? The only place in Alaska to get trained is the Prince William Sound College in Valdez. The nationally accredited program is comprised […]

  • Sports

    Former West High football star Fa’amasino heads to New Mexico State

    by Dave Goldman on Jan 18, 12:14

    Lui Fa’amasino knew the odds. Yet, he went against them and won. Nationally, only 2.5 percent of high schoolers who play football make it to the Division I level. The former West Anchorage High School star graduated two years ago. He moved on to Los Angeles Harbor Junior College. As a linebacker there, his play generated […]