• Forecast
  • News Tip
  • Categories
Temperature Precipitation
Estimated read time
2m 14s

Commentary: LPGA bogeys the call to penalize Thompson

By Dave Goldman 9:17 AM April 7, 2017

Sometimes the pursuit of justice goes too far. Yes, that sounds more like a line for one of John Tracy’s “Reality Checks.”

But there’s no sport more rule oriented, more hyper focused about protocol than golf.

Its greens are manicured with toe nail clippers and works from a rule book that was written by guys who look like Professor Dumbledore. (My kids will be happy with the Harry Potter reference.)

Which is why what happened on Sunday is so baffling.

During the final round of the ANA Inspirational, a Ladies Professional Golf Association (LPGA) major championship, Lexi Thompson had a three shot lead, but between the 12th and 13th holes was told of a rules violation — the mismarking of her ball by an inch. Though unintentional, it would still be expensive; two strokes for playing from the wrong spot and two more for handing in the incorrect scorecard.

The mistake was caught by a viewer who emailed the LPGA. The rules committee reviewed a replay and agreed. But Thompson was 12 holes into Sunday’s round and this was a Saturday violation.

She said afterwards there was no intention to skirt the rules. Everyone believes it was an honest mistake. She even recovered to force a playoff only to lose on the first hole.

There’s something refreshing about a self policing sport, which places a premium on the honor system, but folks at home are not marshals — they’re folks at home.

And once the final putt was sunk Saturday night, the book was closed on round three.

Look at the NFL. You can’t challenge a play after the next play has been run. It’s why coaches are always scrambling for that red flag.

Phil Mickelson is a three-time winner of the green jacket. This week, before the Masters Tournament in Augusta, he admitted to seeing plenty of guys lax in replacing their ball. So why not quietly approach them to be more attentive? Maybe golf needs someone watching everything in a replay booth. But any decisions have to come from the golf course.

Golfers are held to a higher standard. In football, line judges will let the receiver know if he’s lined up offsides and advise to him move back. Basketball referees warn players to keep their elbows down.

I can appreciate the rules committee’s desire to toe the line, but overcorrections like this are simply overbearing. Mistakes are part of the game. If you catch them, you catch them. If not, move on. Because in golf, “Oh by the way…” doesn’t work.

This is a commentary piece. The opinions shared here are not necessarily the opinions of Denali Media or its employees. 


Latest Stories

  • Story Time with Aunt Phil: The WWII battle on the Aleutian chain

    by Laurel Downing Bill on May 26, 12:52

    The battle for the Aleutians became – in proportion to the number of opposing troops – one of the most expensive battles in the Pacific, second only to Iwo Jima. It later was described as the most difficult and dangerous in all modern warfare. U.S. infantry made the first amphibious island landing in its history […]

  • DayBreak

    Mic Check in the Morning: Termination Dust

    by Daybreak Staff on May 26, 12:15

    Dream-pop band Termination Dust will play at the Williwaw in Downtown Anchorage Friday, May 26. They will join The Modern Savage and Alex the Lion. The quartet has released one album, “Familiar Eyes,” which can be purchased on Bandcamp.com. To keep up with the band, you can visit their Facebook page. The concert starts at […]

  • Weather

    Holiday weekend forecast brings variety of weather conditions to Southcentral Alaska

    by Rachael Penton on May 26, 12:10

    If you’re spending some time outdoors in Southcentral Alaska this weekend, be prepared for a variety of weather conditions. A showery weather pattern will keep conditions damp and cooler than normal through Memorial Day. Friday will bring areas of sunshine and mostly dry conditions to start, but scattered showers will again develop across the area during […]

  • DayBreak

    Daybreak Adopt-A-Pet: May 26, 2017

    by Daybreak Staff on May 26, 11:00

    From Anchorage Animal Care and Control: Brett: Brett is a handsome, energetic, playful and affectionate 9-year old boy. He’s a friendly dog who smiles at everyone he meets. Rocky: Rocky is just one of 24 cats up for adoption. All of them would just love a forever home. Caption contest winner: This week’s caption contest […]

  • News

    US Coast Guard says new ships could be stationed in Sitka

    by Associated Press on May 26, 9:13

    SITKA, Alaska (AP) – The U.S. Coast Guard has told Alaska city officials that one or two new ships could be stationed in Sitka. The Daily Sitka Sentinel reported Thursday that Lt. Cmdr. Michael Newell says the Coast Guard is still trying to figure out if it would be feasible to station additional fast response […]

  • News

    Searchers seek 2 missing after boat overturns on Yukon River

    by Associated Press on May 26, 9:07

    BEAVER, Alaska (AP) – Alaska State Troopers are searching for two hunters from the village of Beaver who disappeared after their boat overturned on the Yukon River. A third person in the boat, 45-year-old Kim Andon of Rampart, walked along the river for three days and was found Wednesday about 2 miles  (3.2 kilometers) downriver […]

  • News

    Searchers recover bodies of 2 villagers on egg-hunting trip

    by Associated Press on May 26, 9:02

    SHAKTOOLIK, Alaska (AP) – The bodies of two western Alaska villagers have been recovered from a slough near the village of Shaktoolik. Alaska State Troopers say the bodies of 68-year-old Ella Agibinik of Unalakleet and 75-year-old Dan Takak of Shaktoolik were pulled from the water. Agibinik and Takak had left to hunt for wild bird […]

  • On-Air

    Reality Check w/ John Tracy: Will Sen. Dan Sullivan protect Alaskans’ health care?

    by John Tracy on May 26, 7:44

    The so-called American Health Care Act passed by the U.S. House last month will not be the bill that passes through the Senate. The Obamacare replacement, as written by the House, would cost Alaskans more than anyone else in the country. Thousands of Alaskans who are forced to buy coverage on the exchange market would […]