• Forecast
  • News Tip
  • Categories
Temperature Precipitation
Estimated read time
2m 14s

Commentary: LPGA bogeys the call to penalize Thompson

By Dave Goldman 9:17 AM April 7, 2017

Sometimes the pursuit of justice goes too far. Yes, that sounds more like a line for one of John Tracy’s “Reality Checks.”

But there’s no sport more rule oriented, more hyper focused about protocol than golf.

Its greens are manicured with toe nail clippers and works from a rule book that was written by guys who look like Professor Dumbledore. (My kids will be happy with the Harry Potter reference.)

Which is why what happened on Sunday is so baffling.

During the final round of the ANA Inspirational, a Ladies Professional Golf Association (LPGA) major championship, Lexi Thompson had a three shot lead, but between the 12th and 13th holes was told of a rules violation — the mismarking of her ball by an inch. Though unintentional, it would still be expensive; two strokes for playing from the wrong spot and two more for handing in the incorrect scorecard.

The mistake was caught by a viewer who emailed the LPGA. The rules committee reviewed a replay and agreed. But Thompson was 12 holes into Sunday’s round and this was a Saturday violation.

She said afterwards there was no intention to skirt the rules. Everyone believes it was an honest mistake. She even recovered to force a playoff only to lose on the first hole.

There’s something refreshing about a self policing sport, which places a premium on the honor system, but folks at home are not marshals — they’re folks at home.

And once the final putt was sunk Saturday night, the book was closed on round three.

Look at the NFL. You can’t challenge a play after the next play has been run. It’s why coaches are always scrambling for that red flag.

Phil Mickelson is a three-time winner of the green jacket. This week, before the Masters Tournament in Augusta, he admitted to seeing plenty of guys lax in replacing their ball. So why not quietly approach them to be more attentive? Maybe golf needs someone watching everything in a replay booth. But any decisions have to come from the golf course.

Golfers are held to a higher standard. In football, line judges will let the receiver know if he’s lined up offsides and advise to him move back. Basketball referees warn players to keep their elbows down.

I can appreciate the rules committee’s desire to toe the line, but overcorrections like this are simply overbearing. Mistakes are part of the game. If you catch them, you catch them. If not, move on. Because in golf, “Oh by the way…” doesn’t work.

This is a commentary piece. The opinions shared here are not necessarily the opinions of Denali Media or its employees. 

 

Latest Stories

  • APD: Motorcycle struck car in Old Seward Highway injury crash

    by Chris Klint on Jul 25, 14:53

    Anchorage police are still investigating a collision that left two people injured on the Old Seward Highway Saturday evening, when their motorcycle crashed into a convertible turning onto the highway. Police spokeswoman Renee Oistad had no update Tuesday on the conditions of Eric and Melanie Friedrich, those injured in the wreck at Old Seward and […]

  • Travel Tuesday: The Kratt brothers in Alaska

    by Daybreak Staff on Jul 25, 14:44

    If you’ve got kids, you likely know the Kratt brothers — hosts of Zoboomafoo and the Wild Kratts on PBS. The creative adventuring duo is in Alaska this week, to bring a taste of Alaska, in real time. Hosts Chris and Martin Kratt and the PBS crew have cameras and correspondents spread out across the state to […]

  • News

    Dimond Boulevard closed near Jewel Lake after gunfire inside suidical man’s home

    by KTVA Web Staff on Jul 25, 14:27

    Part of Dimond Boulevard in South Anchorage has been shut down Tuesday afternoon east of Jewel Lake Road, after police said a suicidal man inside a nearby home had fired a gun. Police were asking people to avoid the closed section of Dimond between Arlene and Blackberry streets, spokeswoman Renee Oistad said in a statement. […]

  • News

    Captain rescued from capsize near Kodiak jumps back in to save a crewman

    by Chris Klint on Jul 25, 13:14

    A capsized fishing vessel’s captain jumped back into frigid waters north of Kodiak after being rescued to save one of his crewmen, according to the U.S. Coast Guard. The dramatic rescue, caught on camera by a rescue helicopter, took place Monday afternoon in Kupreanof Strait according to a statement from Coast Guard spokesman Petty Officer […]

  • News

    Senate opens debate on health care reform, despite ‘no’ vote from Murkowski

    by CBS News on Jul 25, 10:54

    Alaska’s senior U.S. senator, Lisa Murkowski, voted against opening Senate debate on health care reform in a highly anticipated decision Tuesday — but the final decision was ultimately made by Vice President Mike Pence. CBS News reported that Murkowski, along with Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) opposed opening debate on the American Health Care Act on […]

  • News

    King crab fishery to open for 5 days in Juneau area

    by Associated Press on Jul 25, 10:36

    JUNEAU, Alaska (AP) – It has been six years since it was legal to catch and haul home a pot full of red or blue king crab out of Juneau area waters. KTOO Public Media reports the Department of Fish and Game said Friday in a release the summer personal use red and blue king […]

  • Immigrant trapped in stifling San Antonio trailer says they shared one breathing hole

    by CBS News on Jul 25, 9:09

    We’re hearing the first accounts from survivors of human smuggling tragedy in San Antonio Texas. They describe their journey from Mexico to the back of a sweltering tractor trailer. When Adan Lara Vega and six people climbed into the back of that trailer in Laredo, Texas, he says it was pitch black and already full. An hour […]

  • News

    Kodiak mayor not pleased with plans for city’s DA position

    by Associated Press on Jul 25, 6:58

    KODIAK, Alaska (AP) – An Alaska city’s district attorney’s office is down its lead position, and officials say a replacement will not be hired. The Kodiak Daily Mirror reported Monday the Director of the Alaska Department of Law’s Criminal Division, John Skidmore, says instead of hiring another district attorney to replace former Kodiak District Attorney […]